We are taught to believe one story. Little Suzy grew up kind
and innocent. She was cherished by her peers, adored by her teachers, and loved
by her parents. She fell in love in high school, and got married soon after
graduation. Going from the protective shelter of her father into her husband’s
home.
Though soon after,
innocent Suzy would be forced to take care of her several young children, do
all of the housework, and care for her husband. As a result, suffering Suzy
would be stripped of the possibility of freedom. Trapped in a flawed system.
My mom was raised in the 1960s and 70s in Grand Junction,
Colorado. She was a cheerleader, track athlete, and gymnast growing up. Her dad
was a school principal and her mom worked for the Chamber of Commerce. Her parents
divorced soon after she graduated high school.
She earned a college degree from the University of Northern
Colorado in Greeley and completed several internships while competing in
collegiate gymnastics throughout college. She got a job, lived in her own
apartment and supported herself financially following college graduation.
It wasn’t until she
was 28 years old that she married my dad, and not until she was 30 that she had
her first child (my brother) in 1994, and then me in 1996. She chose to quit
her job and devote her time and attention to raising her children. A choice
which is criminalized or endorsed, depending on who you ask.
In most social situations, a woman’s accomplishments are
boiled down to her professional achievements. After running into an old friend
when me and my brother were young, my mom was asked how she was doing. A fake
hug, an exchange of information, and at least one pointed question.
“What are you up to?”
My mom, holding me my brother and I’s hands, told her how
our family had recently moved to Fort Collins, how Zak and I were adjusting to
school, about how my dad was doing, about our new dog…
“But what do you do?” her friend pressed
Over the course of my young life, I heard this question more
than once.
As if to say, “What career do you have?... What
accomplishments have you made?”
But for women in professional situations, a woman’s
accomplishments are often reduced to her status as a mother. Passing colored sticky notes, composing emails, or chatting next to the water fountain.
“How do you manage to leave your poor daughter/son at home
all day while you work?”
“Don’t you need to get home to cook dinner?”
My dentist once looked at me with his magnified bifocals
told me that the majority of today’s youth are all spoiled rotten. He
attributed it to the fact that these children did not receive a proper
upbringing, or a mother’s love, because it had become common for both parents
to work.
A woman is simultaneously expected to be a devoted wife, a
caring mother, and a committed worker in her 9-5 job. However, having a career
and having a family are not mutually exclusive endeavors. A woman can have children,
she can have a career, or she can have both.
Like many others in Fort Collins, my mom is part of several “women’s
groups.” She volunteers at the Larimer County Food Bank every Monday with her
friends, Elisa and Mary. She goes to Pilates on Tuesdays and Thursdays and
glassblowing each week with her friend Allison. Occasional lunch dates with Suzanne, Carolyn, Sue, Marian, or Melissa. She has gone to coffee group with her
friends Elisa, Barb, and Sara nearly every week for fifteen years. She is an
alumnae member of Fort Collins National Charity League.
She runs a small business where she makes customized silver
jewelry out of our house in Fort Collins. She has been a Northern Colorado high
school gymnastics official for more than 30 years. And my mom has been an
incredibly dedicated, supportive, and loving parent to me and my brother for
our entire lives.
I once asked my nana (my mom’s mom) if she considered
herself a feminist. She said she believed in equal pay for equal work because
that’s the only part of the feminist movement that matters. She said all the “crazy
ladies” burning their bras were ruining it for everyone else, and that it would
be nice if people still opened the door for her.
Perhaps my mom is a product of her environment. She is not
someone I would classify as a “feminist,” and I don’t think she’d want to be. My
mom is a part of many “groups,” she has a number of responsibilities, and more
than one identity. She is more than her
choice to be a stay-at-home mom. She is a college-graduate, a philanthropist,
an entrepreneur, a friend, an official, a wife, a daughter, a sister, and a
mother. But most importantly, she is an individual.
The danger of the women’s movement is not in believing that
women should be treated equally to men. The danger is not even holding a
protest banner, having strong opinions, or calling yourself a “feminist”. The
danger of the women’s movement lies in the perception that there is only one
story. The belief that every housewife is miserable because she sacrificed her freedom
or that every career-woman is selfish for neglecting her children.
This is the second time I've written a nice long comment and accidentally clicked sign out rather than publish because of where the buttons are located... My apologies.
ReplyDeleteI've heard before the the fundamental difference between Conservatism and Liberalism is that conservatives believe there is only one truth; meanwhile, liberals believe that there are multiple truths. I think that this relates to your story and the quote "The danger of the women’s movement lies in the perception that there is only one story. "
I appreciated how you didn't immediately introduce your mom as your mom. Instead, you gave her her own traits and then tied it into you. This ties into your quote "But most importantly, she is an individual." To even further improve upon this, I would cut out the mention of her being your mother in the third paragraph and let paragraph 5 do all the work that is needed. That would really set it up nicely.
I appreciate that you incorporated dialogue into the story. I promise it really helps to improve the piece.
It's an interesting topic. Our society does have this paradoxical notion of womanhood. For some people, womanhood is defined as motherhood. For others, it's defined as independence, self-reliance, autonomy, etc. Why can't there be a balance? Why must there be only one story?
I would recommend revising this piece to more directly tie into your topic of Fort Collins, Greeley, or Colorado at large. You place your mom in the environment of Colorado, but how does she reflect it? How does it shape her, and how does she shape it? Are any of experiences particular to Colorado / her locality, or would the same thing happen anywhere else. It would have been beneficial to dig into this a little more.
I like how you relate your post directly to the Woman's Movement chapter of Didion's book. I noticed you included quotes which was both effective and engaging! I'm a little confused about the title, so a sentence within the post to explain it might be helpful.
ReplyDeleteI found it interesting that there's an element of disconnectedness to the tone of your post though you're talking about your mom. It might be cool to try and see what would happen if you kept the identity of your mom a secret until the very end, then include your reflections about her and yourself after giving a general picture of who she is and what she does. But I enjoyed reading this!
Mica